Reaver V. Adam VOTING

[JAGeReaver]

JAGeAdam: http://img148.imageshack.us/img148/8766/adamarthascopyaw7.png

JAGeReaver: http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y194/CptTurtle/unnamedcopy.png





NOTE: ARTISTS PARTICIPATING MAY NOT VOTE IN THIS POLL

[JAGeAdam]

I added a third option for me and reaver so I didnt have to continue to click "view poll results"

DO NOT CHOOSE THE THIRD OPTION UNLESS YOU ARE REAVER

[JAGeBoyle]

Wow good entries guys. Both look great.

[JAGeScimitar]

WoW these were both amazing

[JAGeKooru]

I added a third option for me and reaver so I didnt have to continue to click "view poll results"

DO NOT CHOOSE THE THIRD OPTION UNLESS YOU ARE REAVER

http://content.ytmnd.com/content/8/4/8/8483eb09cd3528334ba6ed9132c0f549.jpg

Where's my option. Btw I voted for Adam because I didn't think the background in Reaver's matched the theme. Adam, I wasn't too impressed with your text, you could have chosen a better one. Both were pretty damn good though and I send my praise to both of you.

[JAGeDurf]

Winner is adam with a landslide victory!
-durfy

[JAGeReaver]

Winner is adam with a landslide victory!
-durfy

Atleast I get votes



OH SNAP, I WENT THERE

Poll closes 2morrow

[JAGeDurf]

ROFL i suck i know!
Nobody voted for me.
cries
-durfy

[JAGeConvict]

i liked reavers better

[JAGeRiec]

i too like reavers better

[JAGeDurf]

Convict, Riec, other 3 who voted reaver. you suck
-durfy

[JAGeBoyle]

Both sigs were great.

Text

Adams text was perfect but for some reason did not Jump out at me. Reavers jumped out at me but enough to notice I felt it was too spaced out. I liked it but it was not what I felt it could of been.

Backgrounds

Adams background utilized colors seen in the render wonderfully, and was not over the top, I also felt whatever c4d if he used one gave it a snowing effect of sorts or "something in the air"
Reavers background seemed to be separated from the render, seemed to not be related to it.


Personally I am having to reach for reasons, they were both good sigs but I felt Adams was better.

[JaGe Lee Harvey Oswald]

i wanna see the original renders of both sigs. maybe we should do that regularly for all contests, so we can see how much work they put into doing the sig

[JAGeBoyle]

To be honest. Renders are probably the least important part in your sig. Knowing what render your going to use is important but the background, focal points, depth and text really MAKE the sig.

[JAGeRiec]

Convict, Riec, other 3 who voted reaver. you suck
-durfy

http://i87.photobucket.com/albums/k132/ladyfox17/Achmed.jpg

[JAGeDurf]

http://i87.photobucket.com/albums/k132/ladyfox17/Achmed.jpg
OMG! 500 cool points for you. I love achmed. Jeff Dunham ROCKS!
-durfy

[JAGeReaver]

JAGeAdam is the winner by 3 votes, congratulations!

As this is just a battle, no points are awarded


Great sig

For some reason it wont let me close this thread, so if an admin could kindly close this thread that would be very helpful

[JaGe Lee Harvey Oswald]

I choose this thread to announce I am coming out of the closet.

[JAGeBoyle]

How could we forget LHO coming out of the closet?